A Day in the Life of a Nebula Juror
J M McDermott was on the Novels Jury for the Nebula Awards.
The Nebula Novels Jury sounds really officious. It sounds like we’re sitting around with big, puffy wigs, in long robes, smoking pipes and sipping something very SF Official-sounding, like Nuka Cola or Mana.
And, you’d be exactly right. After I volunteered, the first package they sent me had my pipe (bubbles only for me, thank you), my robe, and my powdered wig, along with my first twelve pack of Jolt. I had to be very careful with the symbols of office. I have to send them all back at the end of my term of service. Actually, I think they’re destined for the Science Fiction Hall of Fame. I only spilled a little bit of soda on the wig. I’m sure it will come right out with a little dry-cleaning.
Also, we got lots of books to read. As anyone who has ever served on a jury like this can attest, the very daunting task of giving each and every book a fair shot means I spent nearly all my free time trying to read a book.
To me, the only real differences has been the robe, the wig, and the pipe.
If you aren’t accustomed to reading mass quantities of books, one can easily get overwhelmed. The real goal is to find hidden talents, hidden voices, and unexpected surprises that other people, and other reviewers, have missed. A good example would be, to me, The Houses of Time by Jamil Nasir. It has an awful, boring cover that does nothing to tell me what the drama of the story is about. The book came from an author who remains, last I checked, off the NY Times Bestseller list, and off the radar of the bloggers and reviewers I follow. .And, I was surprised to discover an exceptionally well-done narrative, with some interesting, memorable characters. I would not have read that book, had it not been for the jury. I know I’ll be looking for more from Mr Nasir in the future.
Another surprise was Felix Gilman’s Thunderer. Again, a terrible, inappropriate cover that looks like something between Peter Pan and Sky Pirates of Istanbul. This debut got some very excellent reviews, and I probably would have picked it up eventually. But, without the urgency of the jury, I would have waited for months to get to it. Now, I have a new favorite debut novelist to follow. (Don’t worry, Mr. Gilman, I’ll be sure not to wear the wig and robes when I’m following you. I make no promises about the bubble pipe. It’s really fun.)
Lots of other books, many were plugged on my blog.
I suspect all the jurors could tell you the same about something. That’s what’s so great about serving on a novels jury. You find books that caught you by surprise.
As a writer, I know my knowledge of my preferred field of fiction increased exponentially as I spent all my free time focused on questions like “What innovative craft techniques created this effect?” or “Is this the most interesting character I’ve met so far this year?” or “Does everyone’s wig itch this much?”.
We are frantically scrambling to read everything in time, and frantically trying to make our unanimous decision. I’ve really got to get back to it, mates!
J M McDermott is the author LAST DRAGON (Wizards of the Coast Discoveries, February 2008). This is his first year on any sort of awards jury. He was called for jury duty once, but the prosecuting attorney didn’t like him.



